After ancient Athens repelled the large army of Atlantis, the story takes a sudden turn towards catastrophe. Due to abnormal earthquakes and floods, the warriors of Athens sank into the ground, and the island of Atlantis disappeared beneath the sea.
Critias notices the strange consistency between this Solon tradition and the ideal state that Socrates spoke of the day before. Recalling memories from his childhood, he prepares to retell the city and its citizens depicted in the myth as the true ancient Athens.
Dialogue Text
Critias (Continued) "However, in later times, abnormal earthquakes and floods occurred, and one day and night of intense disaster struck. At that time, the warriors who were with you all sank into the ground, and the island of Atlantis also sank into the sea and disappeared. Therefore, even now, it is impossible to navigate or explore those waters because a very shallow layer of mud caused by the sinking of the island is an obstacle."
Critias (Continued) The above is a concise summary of what the ancient Critias, as recounted by Socrates and Solon, said. By the way, when you were talking about the state of affairs in that country and the people who live there yesterday, I was surprised and remembered what I am saying now. I realized that much of what Solon told us aligns remarkably with your words, seemingly through some mysterious connection.
Critias (Continued) . However, I did not intend to speak immediately. This was because a long time had passed, and I could not fully recall the details. Therefore, I thought that first, for my own sake, I needed to remember everything thoroughly before speaking about it. So yesterday, I accepted your request without delay. The most difficult part in such cases is constructing a story that fits the purpose, but I thought we would be able to manage somehow.
Critias (Continued) . Therefore, as Timaios said earlier, after leaving here yesterday, I went to where those two were and recounted the story while recalling it. And when I returned home, during the night, I reviewed almost everything and remembered it. As is often said, childhood learning has an amazing ability to be retained in memory. Whether or not I can recall everything that I heard just yesterday, I don't know. However, regarding things that I have been hearing for a long time, it would be no surprise if nothing at all escapes my memory.
Critias (Continued) . At that time, I was listening with great joy and a playful spirit. The old man taught earnestly, and I repeatedly asked questions. Therefore, the story remained within me without fading, like an indelible mark of characters. And this morning, I immediately told the same thing to these two people as well, so that they could have something to talk about together.
Critias (Continued) : Thus, the reason for recounting everything that has come before is now clear. Socrates, I am now ready to recount not only the main points but also every detail exactly as I heard it. Yesterday, you spoke of citizens and a city almost like a myth; now, I will bring those things here as truths. And let us say that the citizens you were thinking about are the people who were spoken of by the priest, our true ancestors. They match perfectly, so if we say they were the people who existed at that time, we will not be far from the truth. We will consult together and strive to respond in a way that is as appropriate as possible to what you have commanded.
Critias (Continued) Therefore, Socrates, we need to consider whether this story aligns with our intentions, or whether we should further explore another story instead of this one.